top of page

1918-19 War-Time London Combination

Manager : Syd King

By the autumn of 1918, as West Ham United prepared for another London Combination campaign, the war was entering its final, desperate phase. Air raids still troubled London, rationing tightened, and families waited anxiously for news from the front. Yet football endured, fragile but determined, and Upton Park remained one of the few places where East Londoners could gather, breathe, and feel something like normality. What no one knew in September was that within nine weeks the guns would fall silent, and the season would become the bridge between wartime improvisation and the rebirth of English football.

 

The 1918/19 campaign was chaotic even by wartime standards. West Ham used a club‑record 62 players, a reflection of the constant movement of servicemen and the sudden availability of professionals once the Armistice was declared. In one November match against Arsenal, two goalkeepers arrived expecting to play; the problem was solved only when Ted Hufton - normally the first choice between the posts - volunteered to fill in at right‑back. It was that kind of season: unpredictable, makeshift, and often faintly absurd.

 

The war’s end on 11 November transformed the footballing landscape almost overnight. Servicemen were not released immediately, but travel restrictions eased, and players who had been scattered across Britain and France began to reappear. Among them was George Kay, who had missed the entire previous season while recovering from shell‑shock. His return, however brief, was greeted warmly. Ted Hufton also re‑emerged after finding himself in the front line as the conflict drew to its close. Their presence gave the side a sense of continuity at a moment when the country was trying to rediscover its footing.

 

The most significant newcomer was James McCrae, the wing‑half from Clyde, whose arrival would prove important in the club’s post‑war development. His introduction to English football was dramatic: during a Combination match at Stamford Bridge, he became the innocent victim of a stone‑thrower in the crowd. McCrae apprehended the culprit himself and then required police protection from hostile home supporters. It was a reminder that even as peace returned, tempers and tensions remained raw.

 

On the field, West Ham were far less formidable than in the previous two seasons. The constant turnover of players made consistency impossible, and the Hammers managed only 65 goals, a sharp drop from their earlier wartime exploits. Only Syd Puddefoot reached double figures, though his influence remained undiminished. He was now the club’s undisputed star, a forward whose reputation stretched far beyond East London. His goals, his presence, and his loyalty through the war years had made him a symbol of the club’s resilience.

 

Yet results mattered little compared to the atmosphere swelling around Upton Park. With peace restored, crowds surged back to football. By the end of the season, nearly a quarter of a million spectators had passed through the turnstiles—an astonishing figure for a competition that had no trophies, no promotion, and no national recognition. People came because they wanted to feel alive again, to stand shoulder to shoulder, to cheer, to forget. Football, more than any other pastime, offered that release.

 

There were moments of joy amid the uncertainty. In January 1919, West Ham thrashed Clapton Orient 7–0 at home, their 13th win in 16 wartime meetings with their East London neighbours. It was a reminder that, even in a season of transition, the Hammers could still summon the old fire.

 

But the most important development came not on the pitch, but in the committee rooms. With the war over, the Football League prepared to expand, and West Ham—buoyed by their wartime performances, their growing support, and their reputation for stability - submitted their application. When the votes were counted in the spring of 1919, the Hammers finished second behind Coventry City, securing their long‑awaited place in the Football League. Coventry, ironically, had finished only fifth in the Southern League Second Division in 1914/15, but the politics of election were rarely straightforward.

 

The reaction from the Southern League was frosty. Only Swindon Town sent a telegram of congratulations. But for Syd King, who had guided the club through the turmoil of war with patience, ingenuity and no small measure of pride, the decision represented the crowning achievement of his long stewardship. West Ham United were no longer a Southern League stalwart - they were now a Football League club, ready to step into a new era.

 

The 1918–19 season may not have produced the goals, the glamour or the dominance of earlier wartime campaigns, but it carried a deeper significance. It marked the end of improvisation and the beginning of ambition. It closed the chapter on four years of uncertainty and opened the door to the modern history of West Ham United.

 

And as the crowds poured back into Upton Park, filling the old ground with noise and hope, it was clear that the club was ready for whatever came next.

Sorry No Image

BRENTFORD
Griffin Park
0 - 2
7 September 1918
Att: 4,000

Williams

Cope

Tirrell

Turley

Johnston

Moore

Burke

Kirsopp

Roberrts

Hamilton

BEST [Guest]

Brentford:

Line-up Unknown

Goals: Stanton, Amos [pen]

Brentford opened the new campaign in confident style at Griffin Park, defeating West Ham United by two goals to nil before a crowd of roughly four thousand. The match offered plenty to hold the eye, even if the general standard seldom rose above the merely serviceable. What could not be disputed was that Brentford fully earned their victory. They enjoyed a slice of fortune in reaching the interval two goals ahead, yet in the second half they were unquestionably the superior side, and only the excellent goalkeeping of Williams - recently of Watford - prevented the margin from becoming more emphatic.
Stanton, the Brentford centre‑half, struck the opening blow after ten minutes, finishing a scrappy passage with a firm shot. Fifteen minutes later Amos added a second from the penalty spot, the award given for a handling offence. West Ham’s forwards never truly settled; their work was ragged throughout, and although they fashioned several chances before the break, none were taken with conviction.
Brentford were without their celebrated centre‑forward, Cock, and in his stead Sgt. Denyer led the line with commendable industry. The home side also unveiled a new left wing pairing, Morley and Chalmers, both of whom made a favourable impression with their pace and understanding. West Ham, too, introduced two or three fresh faces. Of these, Moore at left‑half stood out most prominently, second only to Williams in the visitors’ colours.
Brentford’s organisation, energy and sharper edge in front of goal ultimately proved decisive, and West Ham, despite patches of honest endeavour, could have few complaints at the final outcome.

Sorry No Image

CLAPTON ORIENT
Upton Park
3 - 1 (Ashton, Best, Weir)
14 September 1918
Att: 5,000

FISHER [Guest]

COWNLEY [Guest]

Tirrell

Johnston

BURKINSHAW [Guest]

Moore

Ashton

Burke

McCulloch

WEIR [Guest]

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
Upton Park
0 - 1
21 September 1918
Att: 8,000

Williams

Hodson

Tirrell

Hamilton

Stevenson

Moore

Ashton

Kirsopp

PROCTOR [Guest]

Weir

Best

REPORT:

CHELSEA
Stamford Bridge
1 - 3 (Puddefoot)
28 September 1918
Att: 12,000

Williams

Cownley

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

Massey

Ashton

Burke

Puddefoot

Best

Kirsopp

Chelsea:

Hughes, Middelboe, Rolyat, Halse, Cadman, Pacey, Casey, Langford, Steer, Smith, Kelly

Goals: Smith 2, Langford

West Ham United began with real purpose at Stamford Bridge, forcing the pace through the opening quarter of an hour. Puddefoot, Kirsopp and Burke all drew stern examinations of Middleboe and Roylat, the Chelsea defenders standing up bravely to a lively barrage. Then, almost against the run of play, Chelsea stitched together a neat passing move and Smith finished it with a crisp, low drive to put the home side ahead.
The Hammers replied swiftly. A bout of capital approach work opened space on the right, Best swung over an inviting centre, and Puddefoot met it cleanly to level the scores. West Ham might have turned the match completely - Burke and Kirsopp both found themselves in favourable positions - but neither could apply the decisive touch.
Chelsea’s riposte was ruthless. A dashing break down the flank ended with Casey slipping the ball inside for Langford, who screwed his shot past Rhodes to restore the lead. Five minutes later Smith struck again, this time with a long, looping effort that sailed high into the net - a genuinely brilliant goal - and Chelsea went in at the interval holding a commanding 3–1 advantage.
West Ham resumed with commendable vigour. Ashton drove in a fast shot that was turned behind, and Steer, after a brief injury stoppage, returned to send Hales away for an effort that only just missed the upright. Casey and Steer combined cleverly on another break, but the move was smothered before it could develop. Despite the Hammers’ persistence, Chelsea’s defence held firm, and with no further scoring the match closed in the home side’s favour.

Sorry No Image

ARSENAL
Upton Park
1 - 4 (Moyes)
5 October 1918
Att; 6,500

Williams

Hodson

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

Hamilton

Ashton

MOYES [Guest]

McCulloch

YALLOP [Guest]

Best

REPORT:

CRYSTAL PALACE
Selhurst Park
0 - 0
12 October 1918
Att: 4,000

Williams

Cownley

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

Moore

McCrae

Moyes

Burke

Kirsop

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

QUEENS PARK RANGERS
Upton Park
4 - 1 (Best, Kirsopp, Moyes, Puddefoot)
19 October 1918
Att: 7,000

WOODS [Guest]

Cownley

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

Moore

Allen

Moyes

Puddefoot

Kirsop

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

FULHAM
Craven Cottage
2 - 2 (Kirsopp, Roberts)
26 October 1918
Att: 5,000

Woods

Cownley

Tirrell

Piggott

Hamilton

Moore

Allen

Burke

Roberts

Kirsop

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

BRENTFORD
Upton Park
1 - 3 (Roberts)
2 November 1918
Att: 6,000

Woods

Hodson

Cope

Johnston

Campbell

Moore

Burke

Hamilton

Roberts

Kirsop

Best

REPORT:

CLAPTON ORIENT
Millfields
5 - 1 (Puddefoot 2, Roberts 2, mcCrae)
9 November 1918
Att: 5,000

Hufton

LOWE [Guest]

Cope

Johnston

Stevenson

Campbell

Kirsopp

Roberts

Puddefoot

Best

McCrae

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
Millfields (
match played at Clapton Orients ground)
4 - 1 (Best 2, Kirsopp, McCrae)
16 November 1918
Att; 6,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Stevenson

McCrae

Kirsopp

Moyes

BAKER [Guest]

CunninghamBest

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

CHELSEA
Upton Park
3 - 1 Moyes 2, Cunningham)
23 November 1918
Att; 12,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

McCrae

Kirsopp

Moyes

Baker

Cunningham

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

ARSENAL
Highbury
2 - 0 (Best, Kirsopp)
30 November 1918
Att; 7,000

Woods

Hufton

Hodson

Moore

Hamilton

McCrae

Kirsopp

Moyes

Leafe

Cunningham

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

CRYSTAL PALACE
Upton Park
2 - 0 (Kirsopp, Stevenson)
7 December 1918
Att: 10,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Stevenson

McCrae

Burke

Leafe

Kirsopp

Cunningham

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

QUEENS PARK RANGERS
Loftus Road
0 - 1
14 December 1918
Att: 8,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Stevenson

McCrae

Burke

Kirsopp

Leafe

Cunningham

Best

REPORT:

FULHAM
Upton Park
2 - 1 (Puddefoot 2)
21 December 1918
Att: 10,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Johnston

Stevenson

Lane

Ashton

Kirsopp

Puddefoot

McCrae

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

MILLWALL
The Den
2 - 0 (Dodd, Puddefoot)
25 December 1918
Att: 12,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Campbell

Stevenson

McCrae

Ashton

Kirsopp

Puddefoot

DODD [Guest]

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

MILLWALL
Upton Park
2 - 0 (Dodd, Puddefoot)
26 December 1918
Att; 16,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Campbell

Stevenson

McCrae

Ashton

Kirsopp

Puddefoot

Dodd

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

BRENTFORD
Griffin Park
1 - 3 (Puddefoot)
28 December 1918
Att; 10,000

Hufton

Hodson

Cope

Campbell

Stevenson

McCrae

Yallop

Lane

Puddefoot

Dodd

Best

REPORT:

CLAPTON ORIENT
Upton Park
7 - 0 (Dodd 3, Holmes 2, Burke, Campbell)
4 January 1919
Att: 8,000

Hufton

Cownley

Tirrell

Campbell

Stevenson

Tresadern

Ashton

Dodd

Burke

HOLMES [Guest]

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
Upton Park
2 - 0 (Dodd, Puddefoot)
11 Januaray 1919
Att: 13,000

WEBSTER [Guest]

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

McCrae

Kirsopp

Dodd

Puddefoot

Holmes

Ashton

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

CHELSEA
Stamford Bridge
0 - 0
18 January 1919
Att; 25,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

McCrae

Kirsopp

Dodd

Puddefoot

Roberts

Best

At the close of a vigorous contest an ugly scene unfolded. A youth slipped onto the field and hurled a stone that struck Corporal McCrae, West Ham’s half‑back. McCrae immediately gave chase and caught the offender, only to find himself hemmed in by a swelling crowd of spectators whose sympathies were sharply divided. Police and soldiers moved in quickly, escorting McCrae to the dressing‑rooms before the situation could worsen.

The incident came hard on the heels of another disturbance: only a week earlier a Brentford supporter had been prosecuted for assaulting Puddefoot of West Ham. It was, in short, a troubling reminder of how volatile football crowds could become during moments of high feeling.

Sorry No Image

ARSENAL
Upton Park
1 - 2 (Kirsopp)
25 January 1919
Att; 18,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Stevenson

Campbell

Kirsopp

Dodd

Roberts

McCrae

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

CRYSTAL PALACE
Selhurst Park
0 - 3
1 February 1919
Att; 4,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

Stevenson

Ashton

Dodd

Smith

Tresadern

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

QUEENS PARK RANGERS
Upton Park
0 - 4
8 February 1919
Att: 12,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Fenwick

Moore

Best

Hilsdon

Burke

Tresadern

STEELE [Guest]

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

MILLWALL
The Den
2 - 2 (Holmes, McCrea)
15 February 1919
Att: 25,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

Tresadern

Walden

Dodd

DILLEY [Guest]

Holmes

McCrae

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

BRENTFORD
Upton Park
2 - 1 (Dodd, Bullock [og])
22 February 1919
Att; 16,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

McCrae

Tresadern

Ashton

Dodd

Dilley

Leafe

Steele

Puddefoot missed the game against Brentford, he wired from Scotland that leave had been cancelled.
Although rain fell heavily the gate receipts were over £500 representing a gate of 16,000.

Sorry No Image

CLAPTON ORIENT
Millfields
0 - 0
1 March 1919
Att; 15,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

Tresadern

Ashton

Dodd

Dilley

McCrae

PEARCY [Guest]

REPORT:

TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
Homerton
1 - 0 (Puddefoot)
8 March 1919
Att: 17,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

Tresadern

ASHMOLE [Guest]

NEWTON [Guest]

Puddefoot

McCrae

Best

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

CHELSEA
Upton Park
3 - 3 (Chedgzoy 2, Puddefoot)
15 March 1919
Att; 26,000

Hufton

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Kay

Tresadern

Ashmole

Chedgzoy

Puddefoot

ADAMS [Guest]

Pearcy

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

ARSENAL
Highbury
2 - 3 (Bell, Chedgzoy)
22 March 1919
Att: 20,000

Webster

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Campbell

Tresadern

Leafe

Chedgzoy

McDougall

Bell

McCrae

REPORT:

CRYSTAL PALACE
Upton Park
1 - 3 (Dilley)
29 March 1919
Att; 15,500

Hufton

Cownley

Tirrell

Lane

McCrae

Tresadern

Ashton

Chedgzoy

Dilley

Butcher

Harrison

Crystal Palace claimed a fully deserved 3–1 victory at Upton Park in a match that seldom rose above a modest standard. The pitch, surprisingly firm and true after the recent snowstorm, offered no excuses, yet West Ham never looked comfortable with the lively ball. Puddefoot’s absence - once again unable to obtain leave from his regiment - was keenly felt. Dilley led the line in his stead, but his inexperience told, and only Chedgzoy, operating at inside‑right until a late switch to centre‑forward, and Butcher, newly returned from East Africa, emerged with real credit among the forwards.
The West Ham half‑backs, by contrast, played with admirable resolution, Tresadern especially so. He repeatedly dropped back to assist Tirrell and Cownley, though the latter struggled to match the standard usually set by Cope, another absentee. Palace, however, showed far greater cohesion in attack. Whitworth, leading their line with purpose, scored two excellent goals, and Smith - who claimed the other - was a constant menace.
Palace enjoyed the better of the early exchanges, Hufton saving smartly from White. West Ham then came close to snatching the lead, a lively raid ending with Alderson smothering Butcher’s shot on the goal‑line for a corner. Tresadern later halted Whitworth with the Hammers’ defence beaten, but Palace’s pressure continued. West Ham’s equaliser arrived after thirty‑five minutes: from a corner, Butcher drove in a shot that Alderson saved at full stretch, and with the goalkeeper grounded, Dilley dashed in to force the ball home.
The second half opened tamely, but Palace soon asserted control. After twenty minutes a poor clearance from Tirrell - following a pass‑back from Butcher - fell straight to Smith, who drove in a splendid shot to restore the lead. Five minutes later further defensive lapses allowed Whitworth to score again, and the Palace centre‑forward added a third a minute from time to seal the result.

Sorry No Image

QUEENS PARK RANGERS
Loftus Road
3 - 1 (Chedgzoy, Lewis, Puddefoot)
5 April 1919
Att: 7,000

Hughes

Cope

Tirrell

Lane

Kay

McCrae

Chedgzoy

LEWIS [Guest]

Puddefoot

Bell

Harrison

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

MILLWALL
Upton Park
3 - 2 (Butcher 2, Britton)
12 April 1919
Att; 25,000

Hughes

Cope

Tirrell

Ashton

Kay

Tresadern

Walden

Butcher

BRITTON [Guest]

Bell

TYLER [Guest]

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

FULHAM
Craven Cottage
1 - 1 (Puddefoot)
18 April 1919
Att; 15,000

Hughes

Cope

Brandon

Tresadern

Kay

Lane

TATE [Guest]

Bell

Puddefoot

Butcher

Chedgzoy

REPORT:

Sorry No Image

FULHAM
Upton Park
2 - 1 (Puddefoot 2)
21 April 1919
Att: 16,000

Hughes

Brandon

Cope

Tresadern

Kay

Lane

Chedgzoy

Green

Puddefoot

McCrae

Tate

REPORT:

West Ham United in Wartime 1915-19

West Ham United played a quietly admirable role in offering the public a measure of diversion during the war, the Hammers not only helped lift spirits - if only for an afternoon at a time - but also emerged with sufficient standing to secure a place in the Football League once peace returned.

By 1915, Syd King was deep into his sixteenth year at the helm, and it fell to him to steer the club through the uncertain years ahead. ​ From the opening of the wartime programme in September 1915, King made full use of the opportunity. Players stationed at the Woolwich and Colchester garrisons proved particularly fruitful recruits.

The new league brought together five Football League clubs and seven from the Southern League. The London Combination itself was divided into two parts: the Principal Tournament from September to January, and the Supplementary Tournament from February to May. In 1916/17, West Ham swept to the title with seven points to spare.

Football’s continuation during wartime was not without controversy. Letters appeared in newspapers accusing the authorities of near‑treason for allowing the game to proceed while thousands endured the trenches. The Athletic News countered by highlighting the many sportsmen who had volunteered, and in December 1914 the Footballers’ Battalion was formed within the Middlesex Regiment. 

As the war progressed and troops were constantly redeployed, King’s task of assembling a side grew harder. Some critics claimed West Ham owed their success to “northern imports”, but the Athletic News praised them for winning the title despite constant team changes.

The third wartime season saw the fixture list had been reduced due to travel difficulties. Southampton, Luton, Portsmouth and Watford withdrew, leaving Brentford as the longest journey. Each club met four times, producing a 36‑match programme.

The darkest moment of the season came with the death of Arthur Stallard, killed in action in France in late November, seven months after his final appearance for the club.

In 1918/19, West Ham used a record 62 players. In one match against Arsenal, two goalkeepers arrived expecting to play, only for the issue to be resolved when Hufton, the regular custodian, agreed to fill in at right‑back. The high turnover reflected a happier reality: nine weeks into the season, the war ended. Though servicemen were not released immediately, travel eased and more professionals became available. 

That spring, West Ham applied for election to the Football League and, with strong backing from established clubs, secured their place, finishing second in the poll behind Coventry City - who, ironically, had finished only fifth in the Southern League Second Division in 1914/15. Southern League officials were unimpressed, and only Swindon Town sent a telegram of congratulations.

For Syd King, however, West Ham’s elevation to the Football League stood as the most important and satisfying achievement of his long stewardship

West Ham United elected to the 1919-20

Football League Second Division after World War One

WEST HAM UNITED                                                  ONLINE MUSEUM

bottom of page